inGame footage of various games. In the future I hope to add reviews. ^_^

While some conservatives claim that Obama wants to kill your granny I hesitate to accept that as Obamas sole reason for pushing the health care reform.

From the private insurers point of view it makes perfect sense to oppose the reform ... if they didn't, they'd face an immense decline in profits if either the government option provides better care or if regulations bar insurers from avoiding costs by their current methods.

But it's a bit too simplicistic to merely claim that one party acts out of altruism (or a loathing of old ladies) and the other out of greed.

So, what do you think are the driving motives in this dispute ?

(Note that I don't ask you what you think is the better solution.)

 

Pro (Motives of the health care reform advocates):

  • The Believe that health care is a right, not a privilege (file under altruism).
  • Desire for more government control.
  • An excuse to raise taxes (no one wants to pay more taxes without a good reason).
  • Desperation (they can't get private insurance and hope for the public option).

Con (Motives of the health care reform opponents):

  • Greed / seeking profits (Insurance companies will lose money if forced to provide care to sick)
  • Selfishness ("Why should I pay for your surgery?").
  • Government shouldn't do health care because they are incompetent ().
  • Poor people should die sooner than later.
  • It is not clear how the reform can be financed.
  • A deal with drug companies prohibiting the government to negotiate drug prices can't lower costs.

 

Two key issues that make the health care reform necessary in the eyes of the proponents are quailty and cost.

Quality has been discussed to death and information (and misinformation) is freely available.

Cost is harder to estimate - one simply can't understand what estimated costs of trillions of dollars over decades means for your paycheck. So I started a different thread where I want to compare the personal average cost of health care in different countries.

The personal Cost of Health Care - An international comparison

For example: German average gross income is about €2,500. After deductions (including health insurance) a single person without kids gets to keep about €1,500.

And what can germans do with that money in germany? Why, buy beer, of course. €1,500 get you 1,200 litre of high quality Pilsener beer - twice as much if you don't care about quality and go for the cheap labels.

Health care costs: €185 per month (currently $264)

 

Cheers!


Comments (Page 11)
37 PagesFirst 9 10 11 12 13  Last
on Aug 20, 2009

Melchiz



Quoting WIllythemailboy,
reply 149

You weren't here for the MDY/Blizard topic. That went on for weeks, and I spend hours every day doing research. If you aren't willing to put in the time, you shouldn't start the argument, or at least avoid being the front man for one side's arguments.



I got a chuckle out of this. You spent hours each day doing research for an argument in the off-topic forums of a software company? Incredible.

Why not? I enjoyed myself at least as much doing that as I would have watching TV or playing a game, and as a side benefit several people became more educated on copyright law. That you find this laughable is something I find truly sad. Although it does explain some of your goofball attitudes, you've never seriously discussed them with others.

on Aug 20, 2009

WIllythemailboy

 as a side benefit several people became more educated on copyright law.

I didn't realize that your presence here was so beneficial. I apologize for mocking your devotion to condescending to those who do not share your perspective of the world.

on Aug 20, 2009

And that sort of thing is why I don't feel you to be worth my time debating. To you it's simply a way to rile and annoy people anonymously.

on Aug 20, 2009

Government insurance, er... wait, it's not in there... Kinda looks like Switzerlands system, scary how common that is. Compulsory, individually purchased basic insurance with optional extra coverage. Aside from the whole compulsory thing, it's really popular. We're not real sure how well it works yet, but unlike France, Switzerland hasn't gone bankrupt yet.
But aside from the US the Swiss have the highest per capita healthcare expenses.

Doesn't seem like that much of a goal to go from the most expensive system in the world to the 2nd most expensive system, but I still grant that would be an improvement. Personally I would choose France's system if only because it would piss you off.

on Aug 20, 2009

Melchiz

Quoting WIllythemailboy, reply 143
Nice cop out. Anything you don't feel like answering, or simply can't answer, is just not important enough for your limited time, right?

Considering that I have to stand up against a tag team of ideological allies, it is quite time-consuming. It is difficult to debate an opponent who is outnumbered and afforded no courtesy, yes?

Also, you call me a troll and then hop threads to come harass me without contributing to the discussion. Thank you!

It's more the fact that you pretty much ignored anything that wasn't opinionated completely.

Melchiz

I didn't realize that your presence here was so beneficial. I apologize for mocking your devotion to condescending to those who do not share your perspective of the world.

You said it's hard to debate someone with no courtesy. Tell me, how is that sarcastic post courteus? Surely you want to be above your opponents on the courtesy scale?

 

Finally, if you believed what you were saying so much, wouldn't you have a response? If I read something I don't agree with, I usually think: "well that's not true, because..." or "hmm, I never looked at it that way," or "he does make a good point here." I never think "I don't agree with him, but I can't prove him wrong, so I'll just find one little thing he says that I can attack."

I  guess that's just me.

on Aug 20, 2009

Finally, if you believed what you were saying so much, wouldn't you have a response? If I read something I don't agree with, I usually think: "well that's not true, because..." or "hmm, I never looked at it that way," or "he does make a good point here." I never think "I don't agree with him, but I can't prove him wrong, so I'll just find one little thing he says that I can attack."

I guess that's just me.
I see you're not all that familiar with Joe User. You could write the most intelligent 20 paragraph response with carefully cited references and it all will be ignored to grasp on one little point that can be attacked and usually their interpretation of that one point will be a total misrepresentation of your position.

There is no place where winning an argument is more like winning special olympics than here. There really is no point in discussing anything at all and so I usually don't waste my breath.

The only possible benefit of trying to argue logically is to indicate to any possible open minded lurkers (if one such person exists I'd be surprised) that the discussion is not unanimous in one direction.

But again, really whats the point? When in rome do as the romans do. Nitpick a picayune point ignoring the paragraphs of logic that preceded it. You can laugh to yourself about how much fruitless effort someone put into a post only to have it totally glossed over by some non sequitur. Just don't be foolish enough to waste your time caring what anyone says or trying to convince them that their point of view is not necessarily the only view that a reasonable person may hold. If nothing else pick on a typo and criticise their spelling.

I'm fine with the fact that people hold different views and opinions. What I'm not fine with is when everyone else's opinions are fact and your facts are not only opinions but incorrect opinions that no reasonable person has a right to hold.

If you're looking for any kind of acknowledgemet that your point of view may have some validity even though others may not share it then you better go look somewhere else because you won't find that here.

on Aug 20, 2009

Playground bully bullshit that deserves neither a reply nor respect.

Aroddo -

Your avatar is spookily appropriate.  Slight modification here & there, BO could use it.

...

on Aug 20, 2009

Healthcare demonstration

on Aug 20, 2009

Wow... I'm away for a few days and  suddenly someone released the shitstorm.  

 

Can't you all argue like gentlemen?  

 

P.S. Thats hilarious, but probably out context.

on Aug 20, 2009

Mumblefratz
I see you're not all that familiar with Joe User. You could write the most intelligent 20 paragraph response with carefully cited references and it all will be ignored to grasp on one little point that can be attacked and usually their interpretation of that one point will be a total misrepresentation of your position.

This works outside of Joe User, too. It's common rhetoric especially in american lobbyism.

This scene probably explains 90% of all "discussions" you see on the more biased TV shows.

 

The movie should automatically start at 8:40.

on Aug 20, 2009

what I would also be interested in: what are normal amounts that americans spend for their health care schemes per month? what kind of service would you get for that? I mean I can say it is around 11% of your wage here, a  bit less in germany. so, if you take a relatively normal income of 2.500€ per month, health care would cost you in the vicinity of 250€. that's probably more than you guys pay in the us, no?

on Aug 20, 2009

Shadowhal
what I would also be interested in: what are normal amounts that americans spend for their health care schemes per month? what kind of service would you get for that? I mean I can say it is around 11% of your wage here, a  bit less in germany. so, if you take a relatively normal income of 2.500€ per month, health care would cost you in the vicinity of 250€. that's probably more than you guys pay in the us, no?
No, we pay far more than that.

Decent health insurance for a family if you can get into a good sized "group" is $1200 per month. The same coverage is $1600 per month if it's a small group and probably closer to $1800 for no group at all.

This is good coverage but not the best. Per visit copays are $20, there's a $1000 yearly per person deductible usually with a $2000 cap per family. Perscriptions are $10 for generics, $20 for for preferred drugs and $30 for non preferred drugs.

There are cheaper plans with higher copays and deductibles and more expensive plans with lower copays and deductibles.

on Aug 20, 2009

This scene probably explains 90% of all "discussions" you see on the more biased TV shows.
Thank you for smoking was a great movie and is the blueprint for all astroturfing activities.

In fact Americans for Prosperity originally started out as a tobacco astroturf organization.

http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Americans_for_Prosperity

on Aug 20, 2009

Mumblefratz

Quoting Shadowhal, reply 161what I would also be interested in: what are normal amounts that americans spend for their health care schemes per month? what kind of service would you get for that? I mean I can say it is around 11% of your wage here, a  bit less in germany. so, if you take a relatively normal income of 2.500€ per month, health care would cost you in the vicinity of 250€. that's probably more than you guys pay in the us, no?No, we pay far more than that.
Decent health insurance for a family if you can get into a good sized "group" is $1200 per month. The same coverage is $1600 per month if it's a small group and probably closer to $1800 for no group at all.

This is good coverage but not the best. Per visit copays are $20, there's a $1000 yearly per person deductible usually with a $2000 cap per family. Perscriptions are $10 for generics, $20 for for preferred drugs and $30 for non preferred drugs.

There are cheaper plans with higher copays and deductibles and more expensive plans with lower copays and deductibles.

?! that's freaking neck breaking! and ppl are content with that? I mean barring very high incomes that's a pretty sizable chunk of your income I'd say.

on Aug 20, 2009

Mumblefratz

No, we pay far more than that.
Decent health insurance for a family if you can get into a good sized "group" is $1200 per month. The same coverage is $1600 per month if it's a small group and probably closer to $1800 for no group at all.

This is good coverage but not the best. Per visit copays are $20, there's a $1000 yearly per person deductible usually with a $2000 cap per family. Perscriptions are $10 for generics, $20 for for preferred drugs and $30 for non preferred drugs.

There are cheaper plans with higher copays and deductibles and more expensive plans with lower copays and deductibles.

$1800 per month for health insurance if you live single ??????

What kind of income do you americans get ??? And I mean the average american (whatever that is).

You guys must be freaking rich compared to us if you can afford health care.

 

37 PagesFirst 9 10 11 12 13  Last